Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Imagined Observations, Empirical Illusions

Here is another Jew with a brain that is installed upside down inside his cranium. This time it is Bret Stephens, a columnist and associate editorial writer at the Wall Street Journal. His latest project is titled “Axis of Fantasy vs. Axis of Reality” and subtitled: “France, Israel and Saudi Arabia confront an administration conducting a make-believe foreign policy.” It was published in the Journal on November 12, 2013.

The column is about the people who live in fear because they believe that Iran will become a nuclear threat at some point in the future. Stephens asserts that these people live in the real world. The column is also about the people who point to the current activities of Iran, and reject that possibility. Stephens asserts that these people live in a world of fantasy. Thus, to Bret Stephens, what is imagined may happen in the future is real, whereas what is observed is happening right now is nothing but fantasy. You see, the poor thing sees the world upside down which is a peculiar sort of dyslexia.

The author of the column takes about a third of it to describe the career that Wendy Sherman has had up to now. She is the American who is sitting at the table with the Iranians negotiating on their nuclear program. The aim of Stephens is clearly to badmouth her, something he tries to do by imagining the future and seeing it as clearly as you and I see current realities – or so he believes. Look how he does that: “When the history of foreign policy is written 20 years from now, the career of Wendy Sherman will be instructive.” So you want to know: How is that?

To answer, he cherry picks moments in her career which he believes will denigrate her not because of what she did or failed to do, but because she was associated with people and organizations that will mean failure to some of those who might be reading his column. And so, he tells that Wendy Sherman worked on the Dukakis Campaign, at Fannie Mae, at the State department and at the Albright-Stonebridge Group – moments that amount to no more than a small fraction of the long and illustrious career she has had, and continues to have.

Believing he has by now convinced the readers that Wendy Sherman has been a failure, he tries to rub that perception on the entire Obama administration which is, after all, associated with her. Guilt by association being a very real thing to him even when there is no guilt to be shared, he goes about accomplishing his task in this way: “This administration in particular is stuffed with fail-uppers – the president, the vice president, the secretary of state and the national security adviser, to name a few.” Thus, the vision he had with regard to what history will say about Sherman 20 years from now, has given form to how he rates the current performance of the entire Obama administration.

And this is how he reinforces that vision: “The administration so wanted a deal they would have been prepared to take this one. This is how people for whom [future] consequences are abstractions operate.” He goes on to say you must forget about the current reality of “the pique the French President felt at getting stiffed by the U.S. in his Mali intervention and later in his aborted attack on Syria.” To Stephens, this is no more than fantasy because the reality is that “the French understand that the sole reason Iran has a nuclear program is to build a nuclear weapon.” You see, my friend, to this Jewish author, what is observed is fantasy because what is real is what he speculates the French understand what it is that motivates the Iranians.

Finally, he ends the column with this lamentation: “The tragedy for France and its fellow members of its Axis is that they may lack the power to master a reality they perceive so much more clearly than the Wendy Shermans of this world.”

And the mention of power is the key word that alerts you to the fact that the paranoia engulfing the Bret Stephens of this world can be made to rub off on those in the Congress who have the real power to cause serious damage to the world.

You sound the alarm, and you put these people on notice that you'll be watching them like a hawk