Saturday, February 16, 2019

Between Realism and the Dream of past Glories

Science, technology and industry have made the world so small, anything that happens in one place affects all the places on the globe, in one fashion or another.

For this reason, those that have not brought themselves to thinking globally in what they say or do, have little chance of advancing whatever cause they champion. Thus, you'll find that today, most people think globally … including those that hark back to a time when globalism was a strange something that nobody knew how to define. These people worship a has-been era, as they remain motivated by the belief that the glorious past is still alive, but taking a nap and about to wake-up and rule again.

Two authors who believe in the global phenomenon but from very different angles, have pronounced themselves lately. They wrote about the crisis in Venezuela, and how America is handling the situation there.

On February 12, 2019 Benny Avni wrote a piece under the title: “Why Venezuela's struggle for freedom has Iran's rulers worried,” a column that was published in the New York Post. Two days later, Mark N. Katz wrote a piece under the title: “Suspicion over US motives in Latin America warranted,” and the subtitle: “Elliott Abrams should answer Ilhan Omar's questions,” an article that was published in the New York Daily News.

Benny Avni worships the colonial era, which is a time when the world was populated by human predators in the business of hunting down human preys, and robbing them of their possessions. This is why Avni is firmly wedded to the idea that the Israeli genocide of the Palestinian people by Jewish hunters that come from all over the globe, is a marvelous phenomenon that should continue till the hunters acquire all that they want.

But Israel is situated in the Middle East where there is also Iran, a nation that is regarded by the Jews in Israel and America—such as Benny Avni—as an impediment to Israel's effort at implementing its genocidal designs on the people of Palestine. Moreover, this being a globalized world, it happens that Iran and Venezuela are in one and the same boat, according to Benny Avni. This is why, to escape this unpleasant reality, he could not help but be drawn to reveries of the golden era of colonialism.

And so, to Benny Avni, the struggle in Venezuela and Iran boils down to the following:

“The regimes in Tehran and Caracas are birds of a feather. Iran faces growing internal dissent and external sanctions. Ditto for the Bolivarian Republic. Venezuelans seem close to toppling the regime. Iran may follow a similar course. In both cases, tumbling oil prices transformed leading petroleum exporters into basket cases. No wonder the two are such close friends. The late Hugo Chavez merged the Latin-tinged 'Yankee Go Home' with the Persian 'Death to America' chants. The two regimes find themselves in the same boat. Trump's administration has used pressure points in support of Venezuelan and Iranian regime opponents. In Venezuela, the streets erupted. Iran's clerics must tremble as they watch their allies teeter”.

As can be seen, Avni is obsessed with the idea that the world is made of good and evil. He believes that those who are not with us are against us, and this makes them evil. It is why he firmly believes that they will lose in the end. In fact, the end must be nearing as demonstrated by the difficult time that Venezuela and Iran are experiencing. Avni has no proof that the clerics in Iran are trembling, but his obsession is so powerful, it turned his imagination into a reality he cannot shake off.

As to Mark Katz, the struggle in Venezuela boils down to the following:

“What captivated those who follow the crisis in Venezuela was a clash between Rep. Ilhan Omar and Elliott Abrams. Omar called into question whether Abrams was acting in good faith. She recalled his role when the US government illegally provided aid to the Nicaraguan Contras to fight the Marxist regime there, and he pleaded guilty about lying to Congress. This exchange was significant because it represented the clash of two worldviews concerning American foreign policy. Abrams sees the goal of American foreign policy as doing good for the people of other countries. But for Omar, US policy involved the practice of overthrowing democratically elected leaders and replacing them with military rule. The overthrows of Guatemala's Jacobo Arbenz in 1954 and Chile's Salvador Allende in 1973 are examples”.

As can be seen, Mark Katz sees and teaches reality as it is, not as he wishes it were. If he has an agenda of his own, he keeps it to himself, being engaged in a line of work that bestowed on him the fiduciary duty of being truthful and impartial.

This is why Mark Katz is a teacher whereas Benny Avni is a modern-day partisan pundit.