Saturday, April 1, 2017

Twisted Arguments to shift the Blame

There is an American habit that's “curiouser and curiouser” as it is, and that's also exploited to the hilt once in a while. Have you ever heard someone say 'the whole world has gone mad'?

The Americans often use that expression when they mean to communicate that a handful of people – not the whole world; not even all of America – have gone mad. Well, you may call it an acceptable idiom of the kind you find in any language, and you could be right. The trouble, however, is that these same people never say 'the whole world has gone exceptional' to mean that a handful of new immigrants accomplished something extraordinary. But that's beside the point.

Where things start to get sticky is when professional commentators use that American habit to promote a point of view that has no merit. What they do is take something that concerns a single individual and make it sound like it is shared by the whole world. At other times, they do the opposite in that they take something common to a multitude of people, and make it sound like it only concerns a single individual.

You'll find an example of such use of the American habit in an article that came under the title: “Bill Maher makes us dumb,” written by Steven A. Cook and Michael Brooks, and published on March 26, 2017 in Salon Magazine. The article also has a double-entry subtitle. One goes like this: “How ignorance, fear and stupid pop-culture clichés shape Americans' view of the Middle East.” The other goes like this: “Americans used to be just ignorant about Muslims and the Middle East. Now we're also fearful, stupid and wrong”.

Those who are old enough to have been around during the Watergate era may remember that this American habit and its opposite were played out simultaneously. It is that the commentators of that time blamed the degeneration of the political system on a single individual: President Richard Milhous Nixon. And they blamed the street crimes that were committed by individuals on the entire society.

Fast forward forty years, and you catch Steven Cook and Michael Brooks do two contradictory things at the same time. As can be seen in the title and the two subtitles, they blame the wrong attitude that some Americans display towards the Muslims on Bill Maher alone. And in the same breath, they blame that same wrong attitude on the entire American society. Go figure.

But really, why do they do this? Well, let's say they do it because they don't want to blame what's unfolding among some Americans on the real culprits who are Fox News and the mob of Jewish pundits. These are not a single individual; and they are not the entire American society. Call them what you want, but many would agree they are a part of the Jewish Hate and Incitement Machine (JHAIM).

Long before the fall of the Soviet Union, JHAIM was scheming to engineer a falling out between the Muslims – especially what they used to call the Arab core – and the West. It was not easy for them to score because the object of Western hatred was the Communist villain. But when that villain fell, the Jews moved quickly to replace it with the Muslims and the Arabs … and that's when they scored a success.

I was one of the first to feel the effect of their machinations in this regard. While a few of them knew I was Christian, others did not. They told me what I must do to be rewarded with successes beyond my wildest dream. To make a long story short, believing that I was Muslim, they wanted to make me what they later made of Salman Rushdie. I deemed this idea to be so repugnant, I rejected it instantly and never relented despite their continued pressure on me.

Decades later, I think of that offer to have been such a horrible thing; if I had to choose between two forms of punishment, I would choose to spend an entire day watching video of animals crapping one after the other, than spend one minute watching Fox News showing Muslims denigrate Islam, African Americans denigrate Africans or Asian Americans denigrate Asians. This is what the folks at Fox News do for a living. To my mind, if cowardice can be so intense as to become a crime, the mangled creatures at Fox News are showing us what that crime would look like.

Steven Cook and Michael Brooks may not be there yet, but they better back off that road before they find themselves worth less than organic fertilizer.