Thursday, September 19, 2013

The Era of Central Banks as Pawnshops

In light of Ben Bernanke's reluctance to “taper” the buying of bonds – something he promised he will do by now but then seems to have changed his mind – it is beginning to look like America is entering a new era and dragging the world with it. Bernanke is chairman of the central bank in the world's largest economy whose currency, the dollar, also happens to serve as the world's reserve currency. Thus, America's influence is sizable, and what happens there is bound to become the template that the rest of the world will want to emulate.

What is happening in America and apparently will continue to happen for a while longer, is that the central bank maintains the posture of pawnshop to the nation. Being the bank of last resort, the Fed, as it is affectionately called, will continue to buy anything that anyone will convert into a bond. It is the Fed's way to make sure that plenty of cash is pumped into the financial system, a move that Bernanke sees as necessary to prevent the economy, whose growth is already anemic, from shrinking even further.

But all this must have ramifications too difficult to predict at this time with any certainty. All we can do is remind ourselves of what money is, and how it came to be. We should then keep our eyes open, and follow closely the events as they unfold. Maybe it will happen someday that someone will see a danger gather in the distance, and sound the alarm to tell the world of a looming disaster before it strikes.

As it happens in all such cases, the danger that may come – if it comes – will strike the currencies. So we ask: What's the worth of a currency like say, the dollar for example? Well, it all depends on how much of it is in circulation, and how much the people that want it clamor to own it. That is, it all depends on the supply-demand equation. But because a number of problems have cropped up in the past with printed (or fiat) money, some people have called for a return to the gold standard. To understand what that is; indeed to understand what money is, we need to go back to when human beings started to trade with each other.

As hunters and gatherers, members of the same family or the same clan or tribe shared everything that the group was able to assemble in a given day. But there came a time when a group such as that, needed to make peace or start a cordial relation with other groups and so, to demonstrate their goodwill, the groups exchanged gifts. That is, if one group had a surplus of something, it was happy to exchange it for the surplus of another family or clan or tribe.

When the goods and services that were ready to be exchanged became more varied, the pleasantries of trading gifts with nearby neighbors evolved to become the necessity to barter goods and services with people that came from far away bearing a larger variety of goods or services such as entertainment and fortune telling. They all assembled in the same marketplace where they haggled as each individual sought to obtain the most in exchange for giving away the least. Here, for the first time, the supply-demand equation played a role in determining the value of the items being traded.

Eventually, the precious metals and other artifacts became the items that people chose to exchange for goods or services. The trend may have started when they were exchanging products they gathered from nature, but the choice turned out to be a useful method when the humans advanced a few more notches and started to fabricate some products. This was the time when people who learned to make elaborate products such as shoes, clothes, pottery or furniture opened their own shops where they made and sold products in exchange for the precious metals. These people were the tradesmen and the craftsmen that made the mercantile era.

Up to this point, people were in control of their economic well being. That is, the harder they worked, the more they produced and the more they owned of what they could exchange for what they did not have. Then came the printed money, and the control of one's economic destiny passed to someone else. It went to those who printed the money and those who were close to them. Having an easier access to money, these people had a more direct influence on the economy than the trades and crafts people who produced the goods and services forming the economy in the first place.

The bankers and the employees of other financial institutions are now the people in control of the economy, and the ones who receive the cash that the central banks print and hand to them in exchange for bonds that may or may not represent the value assigned to them. In fact, the banks which, in times past, were required by law to have a set reserve in gold, no longer have this restriction. They borrow as much as they want from the central bank in exchange for bonds to which they themselves assign a “fair value” which they say is determined by the supply-demand equation.

The trick, however, is that both the supply and the demand parts of the equation are set by the people who package and sell the bonds. They and their colleagues of the same financial institutions buy and sell the bonds inside a bubble where they often take something worth little, and make it look attractive enough to soak to the central bank that has become a pawnshop, in exchange for good money.

Keep your eyes open, my friend for, you may be the first to see danger gather in the distance, and sound the alarm to wake us up to the fact that good money may no longer be as good as it looks.