Friday, August 14, 2015

Time for a simple Lesson in Physics

Senator Charles Schumer who came out against the Iran nuclear deal has repeated – in a speech he gave at New York University on August 11, 2015 – the saying that one of the reasons he rejects the deal is that some components for making an atom bomb do not involve nuclear isotopes.

This was a response to the criticism that a 24 days notice given to the Iranians about an impending inspection is not something to worry about because nuclear material leaves traces that last thousands of years. And so, Schumer responded that 24 days will give the Iranians enough time to hide or remove the non radio-active components. The problem is that he did not say what components he had in mind.

Well, perhaps the senator doesn't know that once you have the nuclear material enriched to the desired level – something he is not raising questions about – it will take no more than a small shop to make the rest of the components and assemble them into a bomb. The equipment you'll need will be of the regular machine shop type; nothing more sophisticated than that. In addition, you'll need a high performance multi-trace oscilloscope, and small charge capacitors.

Three or four decades ago, you might have had a difficult time getting your hands on that type of oscilloscopes and that type of capacitors because the world was mostly analogue, and marching at megacycle speeds. Today, however, the world is mostly digital, and marching at teracycle speeds. This has turned those oscilloscopes and those capacitors into shelf items, putting them at the disposal of anyone that wants them. To spot them in a shop might heighten someone's level of curiosity, but they do not constitute proof that something nefarious has been going on here.

But really, what can you do with an oscilloscope of that kind, and a bunch of small charge capacitors? Well, you can use the capacitors to design a mechanism that delivers an electric charge to several points simultaneously. And you can use the oscilloscope to see how simultaneous the timing is.

To understand how important this is, you need to know that a conductor, such as a wire, has three properties that can be measured. They are: resistance, inductance and capacitance. Each of these plays a role in determining the speed with which an electric current moves in a conductor. When detonating a nuclear bomb, you need to shrink the size of the uranium ball at its core to raise its critical mass, ensure that a chain reaction will take place and that it will be sustained. You do this using dynamite that squeezes the ball on many sides simultaneously.

If the electric charge that ignites the dynamite is not delivered at the exact same moment to all the sides, the part that gets squeezed first will release the sub-atomic particles at a rate dense enough to start the chain reaction (which is another way to say nuclear explosion). But this alone will not be enough to sustain the chain reaction because the heat generated by the explosion will melt the rest of the uranium ball before all the sides had had the time to get squeezed. And you'll end up with a low yield nuclear explosion or even a dud.

The way to fix this problem is to add capacitors of the correct size to the circuitry so as to make all the sides receive the electric charge at the same time. Once you test this, and the oscilloscope shows that you have the right combination, you still need to conduct an experiment where real dynamite – or any kind of high yield chemical explosive – is used.

You will not, however, use a core that is made of radio-active material. Instead, you will use a metal of comparable density such as lead, for example. With this, you will determine whether or not your mechanism can squeeze the core hard enough to give it a higher mass – high enough to be critical when it is uranium.

To do this, you do not need to be in a shop. In fact, miners and construction workers use explosives all the time, and if you want to conduct a clandestine experiment, you can use that as cover to do it. You will collect the data you need to see if the firing mechanism as well as the dynamite you'll be using in the detonation of the nuclear core, work as well as expected. And no one will know or even suspect what you're doing.

Thus, the fears that Senator Schumer is voicing about hiding the components of a nuclear bomb in a shop are but a figment of his paranoid imagination. What's needed among the nations of the world are goodwill and trust, not a whip in the hands of a clumsy eunuch.